The End of ICL-CES
One of the challenges with a computing curriculum is that it is very quickly out of date. Technology moves fast, and as an example, AI has a brief mention on current UK syllabi. The jobs that current students will take probably don't have names yet, as they have yet to be invented. I've seen this all through my career as a computing science teacher and lecturer. Syllabi content has to be consulted upon, agreed and ratified. A particular syllabus will be in use for ten or more years. Currently I have to teach students about network hubs, disk thrashing, optical media, defragmentation and so on, because a question could potentially appear in a future exam paper. GCSE, and to a lesser extent A level are currently (at the time of writing, 2026) undergoing consultations, and a revised GCSE Computing is expected around 2028.
Between the first editions of the books (from 1969 into the mid 70s), and the late 1970s, technology of course had evolved. In the late 70s, microcomputers such as the Commodore PET and the RM 380Z were starting to appear in British schools. They had VDUs that provided near-instantaneous output. Program code could be input, run, edited and run again in a matter of seconds. Computing was changing quickly, from mainly the batch processing model to the interactive local model. ICL manufactured mainframe and mini computers. A whole raft of manufacturers were releasing or about to release many different models of affordable micro computers. Initially when I first wrote this section, I thought that this was a problem for ICL, who didn't operate in this space. Evidence suggests that it wasn't as big of a problem as I initially thought. It seems that the creation of (for example) CESIL interpreters for microcomputers was encouraged and welcomed. The newsletters bear this out, and the Computer Education Group's journal Computer Education carried articles on some of them, including MICRO-CESIL by Chris Robinson of LEASCO Software (No. 28, February 1978) and a CESIL system for the RML 380Z developed at Sandhurst School in Berkshire (No. 32, June 1979). In 1982 CES edited and published data processing case studies for the Microelectronics Education Programme (MEP), with software for the RML 380Z, and the June 1983 newsletter announced five pieces of Computer Studies software for the BBC Model B, with RML 380Z versions already planned (Newsletters No. 40 and 41).
ICL had no school microcomputer and was not a significant player in the microcomputer market, and this must have crossed the minds of ICL executives outside the CES group. A large part of their ICL-CES programming element was based around ICL technology. Write your code on pre-printed sheets, send them off to an operator to produce punch cards or paper tape, which would then be input into an ICL mainframe, and then wait up to a week or so for the results. This was the modus operandi at the start of the ICL-CES program but it was becoming old-fashioned and out of touch towards the end.
The batch model was there from the very beginning. When Hoskyns first set out the scheme in 1968, pupils' programs were to be written on coding sheets, posted to CES, punched onto tape and run on a bureau computer, with a target turnaround of 72 hours. By December 1969 the project's panel of local authority advisers was already hearing about delays, and in 1971 an HMI note called ICL/CES's processing of schools' programs "very slow and not satisfactory" (Goldstein papers, GG/2/1). That same month the panel split evenly over whether to use BASIC, with its supporters valuing that it could be used "conversationally". Ironically, Hoskyns' original 1968 plan also included a cheap, purpose-built school computer costing around £2,000. It was never built, but a decade later microcomputers did that job. (Schools Council file SCC/355/363/014, UCL Institute of Education Archives. See How Computer Education in Schools began.)
The CES Advisory Council was already discussing microprocessors in the mid-1970s. In December 1976 it asked ICL to present a paper on how it planned to respond to "the significant developments in microprocessors and the already considerable impact of these devices in education". In March 1977 Steve Bacon said CES was well placed to tell ICL's hardware developers what schools needed, but should not become involved in selling or supporting hardware. At the same meeting, members heard that a five-user BASIC system could now be bought for £3,000, that Hampshire had bought two microprocessors for schools, and that Durham was considering two. By October 1977 the South West panel was reporting that more schools and colleges were getting their own hardware, in some cases old computers and in others microprocessors. (Papers of Gabriel Goldstein, GG/8/5, UCL Institute of Education Archives.)
Some students liked CESIL, but others didn't. Jeff Minter, the famous games programmer, didn't like it, and was frustrated with the old school method of programming. (Minter, Jeff, and Patrick Minter. A History of Llamasoft, s3.amazonaws.com/lsshop/AHistoryofLlamasoft.pdf.)
Schools had spent a lot of money on teaching materials where a large proportion of the course involved programming in a (now) old-fashioned way. So of course for a few years they continued teaching using it. Students were learning CESIL and BASIC, but making use of (for example) an actual Commodore PET sitting in the corner of the room. Some teachers with access to a microcomputer even created CESIL translators (see last comment).
The concepts and principles that were part of the ICL-CES programme were still valuable knowledge, but without an in-class translator, teenagers would have viewed this programming execution model as old fashioned, frustrating and not as fun or interesting as directly interacting with a microcomputer.
The last years, through the newsletters
What makes the sale surprising is how successful CES looked only a few years before it. In November 1979 the Directors of ICL held an anniversary dinner at Claridge's to celebrate the project's tenth birthday. Over 2000 schools and colleges were basing their computer education courses on CES materials, and the newsletter described CES as "the most widely used source" of materials and advice in the field (Newsletter No. 34, January 1980). The subject itself was still growing fast: more than 21,000 students were entered for CSE or O level Computer Studies in 1977, and more than 25,600 sat the O level alone in 1981, over 50% more than the year before (Newsletters No. 32 and 39). As late as June 1983, Computer Education put the number of schools using CES at some 3000 (No. 44).
The cracks show in the staffing. In August 1981 Steve Bacon left to become Derbyshire's county adviser for computer education, and Ian Irving moved to the Nottinghamshire Educational Computing Training Centre. Their posts stayed empty for the best part of a year, and with only four people left, the development of new materials slowed; Teachers' Guide 2 was delayed by more than a year (Newsletters No. 38 and 40). ICL then recruited strongly in 1982, bringing the team to nine, which the December 1982 newsletter called "an indication of ICL's continuing support for computer education" (Newsletter No. 40).
That support didn't last. In March 1983 Colin Monson left to become Berkshire's Adviser for Computer Related Education, and the June 1983 newsletter noted that CES had "once again acted as a provider of Local Authority computing advisers" (Newsletter No. 41). As local authorities appointed computer advisers to support microcomputers in schools, CES's experienced staff were exactly the people they wanted. By October 1983 the project had been sold.
Why ICL sold
There is still much research to do, but I think I can understand why ICL sold the CES project in 1983. ICL itself was struggling with its own financial issues, partly due to the influx of cheaper microcomputers and increased competition from companies such as IBM, leading to a takeover of ICL by STC in 1984. Its product line, built around mainframes and minicomputers, was not a good fit for schools that were now buying microcomputers. Acorn was seemingly in a stronger position with their home micros and also being chosen as the computer for 'The Computer Literacy Project'.
Acorn didn't republish any of the computer studies materials. They republished Computers, Information and You (a relatively small ~116 page book initially published by ICL only a few months previous in mid 1983), first with just a logo change on the cover, and then later in a new style for a further reprinting. Work on the second book, The Information Age, had only just begun at ICL-CES before Acorn acquired the project for under £100k in October 1983, and Acorn saw it through to publication.
However, Acorn were already in financial trouble when they acquired CES, due to issues with the Electron, a failed US expansion and the UK home microcomputer bubble bursting. Acorn quickly made redundancies, reducing the CES team (which had been nine strong at the end of 1982) from six to three and moving them from Acorn's new Maidenhead office to Cambridge in July 1984. Reviews in Computer Education still gave Acorn CES's address as The Hermitage, Bath Road, Taplow, Maidenhead in November 1984 (No. 48), but by June 1986 it was Unit 8, Cambridge Technopark, 645 Newmarket Road, Cambridge, selling the Living with Computers series (No. 53). In February 1987 the journal opened with an article by Garry Neale, by then at Acorn Computers in Cambridge. Partly a promotion of Acorn's range, it said that Acorn CES "offers a complete, integrated information technology course for schools" (No. 55).
Gill Roberts (formerly Blackwell), who was one of the team, has described what that was like in her account of her time at CES. In the summer of 1983, just as Computers, Information and You and its six programs were ready for schools, "the atmosphere in the office was strange", and the team soon learnt that ICL had agreed to sell them to Chris Curry and Hermann Hauser of Acorn. By October ICL had paid them redundancy, and Acorn had installed them in The Hermitage, a large Edwardian house in Maidenhead; inevitably, they became "Hermann's Hermits". Colin Monson had already left, and David Roberts did not make the move. Gill became Information Officer, travelling through England, Wales and Northern Ireland to demonstrate the materials to LEA education officers and teachers, while Garry Neale, Jenny Nash and Wyn James wrote The Information Age.
The end came suddenly. On 10 June 1984 Acorn treated its staff and their families to a day at Silverstone. The next day the CES team were called to the board room, told that the project was moving to Cambridge, and each handed a sealed envelope. Gill's told her she was redundant, with six weeks to find a teaching post before September.
Following the Olivetti bailout in February 1985, Acorn seemed to shift focus toward educational software and training materials, all of which was eventually rolled into Acornsoft. CES faded away in the aftermath. No more secondary books were ever released, and I suspect that only work on the 11–13 Living with Computers series continued at Acorn. Independent computer studies textbooks were beginning to appear, although many schools continued to at least dip in and out of the CES textbooks until the mid-80s. (One of my ICL-CES textbooks has a loan date to a student in a class of 1987!)
Looking back in 1995, an article in Computer Education on government initiatives and IT in schools summed up ICL's part in all this: before the microcomputer arrived, ICL was the major British computer manufacturer, its sponsorship did much to promote the teaching of computer studies in the UK, and "ICL-CES was established specifically for this purpose" (No. 81, November 1995, p. 8).
- Article from Acorn User, October 1983
- Article from Acorn User, April 1984
- Article from Acorn User, October 1985
- Acornsoft Catalogue, Winter 1984, featuring CES
The Centre for Computing History details the only materials released under the Acorn CES branding.