How Computer Education in Schools began
On 31 March 2026 I visited the UCL Institute of Education Library to read a Schools Council file on the Computer Education in Schools (CES) project. I already knew that CES had been started by the management consultancy John Hoskyns & Co and was later taken over by ICL. What I didn't know was how it got from one to the other. The file was kept by R. Sibson, Secretary of the Schools Council, and runs from September 1968 to January 1972. It fills in that story, and it records the beginnings of CESIL along the way. For the first few years under ICL, I've added detail from the early ICL-CES newsletters located in the ICL archive at the University of Manchester, the Science Museum at Wroughton and courtesy of Colin Monson.
A consultancy with a plan (1968)
Hoskyns set up CES in February 1968. In September, one of its directors, Christopher Wysock-Wright, visited the Department of Education and Science (DES) to explain the plan. He reported that 24 local education authorities, and 1,200 of the 2,000 secondary schools CES had contacted in the South East, had said they were interested.
The offer was a one-year course of about 90 hours, aimed first at sixth formers and the top streams of secondary moderns, and eventually at every pupil as part of their general education. It was explicitly not just for mathematicians. A school paid £240 for the teacher's materials and training, plus £7 per pupil. Schools needed no computer of their own: pupils wrote programs on coding sheets, the teacher posted them to CES, and CES staff punched them onto tape, ran them on an Elliott 903 and sent the results back, aiming for a 72-hour turnaround.
The longer-term ambition was a purpose-built school computer costing around £2,000. Wysock-Wright dismissed IBM's desk-top machine for schools as a mere "number cruncher". The directors were John Hoskyns, Dr Bryan Thwaites of Westfield College (founder of the School Mathematics Project), R. P. Tomlin and Wysock-Wright. CES asked the DES for a grant and invited it to sit on an Advisory Council.
A set of CES notes on "the formation of CES, its aims and objectives", which survives in Gabriel Goldstein's papers, sets out the thinking behind the scheme. Computer education was nothing new, the notes said, but years of working parties and recommendations had achieved little. Teachers had no formal training, computers and computer time were expensive, data preparation caused a bottleneck, and there were arguments over which language to teach and whether to use terminals or small desk-top machines. No manufacturer had "really looked at the problems, in depth, from the schools point of view". After research amounting to three man-years, CES proposed a national organisation, financed at first by the Government and supported by local authorities and independent schools. It would design courses, train teachers, act as a bureau for preparing and running pupils' programs, and advise schools on equipment.
Kept at arm's length
The official response was cool. D. L. Corder at the DES saw little prospect of financial help. Sibson went further. In a memo of 17 October 1968 he wrote that there should be no formal link between the Schools Council and CES, nor anything CES could use in its publicity. He pointed out that the Council had already advised IBM on the very desk-top computer Wysock-Wright had dismissed, and recorded "serious reservations" about the scheme. Even so, he kept the file open, and CES kept writing to him for the next three years.
The launch at Romford
CES launched publicly on 4 November 1968 with a conference and lunch at the Royal Liberty School in Romford, which already had its own Elliott 903. Professor Stanley Gill, outgoing President of the British Computer Society, and Bryan Thwaites spoke, and guests watched pupils programming over closed-circuit television. The invitation predicted that the computer terminal would soon be as much a part of school equipment as the blackboard. Sibson did not attend.
Pilots, panels and a new language (1969)
Through 1969 CES built its course with a panel of LEA advisers, which grew to cover dozens of authorities in England and Scotland. It ran pilots at Winchester College, with seven 15-year-old non-mathematicians, and at Westfield College, with 12 volunteers from Inner London schools. The draft textbook was judged too long-winded and rewritten as a 300-page A4 ring binder. Teacher training ran at the University of Surrey's annexe in Godalming in July and August 1969, as 12 consecutive days with access to digital, analogue and hybrid computers.
The liveliest debate was about programming languages. CES wanted pupils to learn a low-level language so they were not isolated from the machine, and chose SIR, the Elliott 903's assembly language, because it had only 16 instructions. Alongside it sat a simpler teaching language. It first appears in the February 1969 panel minutes as "the fictitious language". A paper from April 1969 explains that CESIL was originally specified as an ideal language to use as a "yard stick", and was run through a translator rather than a full compiler. By May the textbook outline named it the CES Instructional Language and used it for the first programming chapters before moving on to SIR. Not everyone was convinced: one panel member was already arguing that BASIC would be better.
ICL takes over (1969)
On 27 August 1969 Wysock-Wright wrote to Sibson in confidence. After 18 months, he said, the research and development phase was complete and the project needed a larger organisation, so ICL would take it over from 1 September. J. F. Farrer became manager, and the course was published as The Fundamentals of Computing. According to The Guardian's report, 1,200 children in 27 schools had started using the package and around 2,000 schools had enquired.
The Computer Education Group's journal, Computer Education, reported the takeover in its October 1969 issue (No. 3), with a list of the first schools using the package. ICL would market the course worldwide except in the USA and South America, while Wysock-Wright stayed with John Hoskyns, hoping to develop the American market. The journal's editorial called the move "a shrewd one by ICL", since schools using CES would become familiar with ICL equipment.
At ICL's first panel meeting in October 1969, Farrer explained the company's thinking. ICL had set up its own working party on computing in schools and found that Hoskyns had already done what it planned. He also drew on the Bellis report in Scotland. He spoke of educating a generation that would see the computer as a slave rather than a monster, and admitted frankly that pupils arriving with some computing background would save ICL money. ICL wrote a simulator so that the ICL 1900 computers many local authorities already owned could run the pupils' programs.
By December 1969 schools had sent in about 850 programs in CESIL and 300 in SIR. Arts pupils were coping as well as scientists. A draft CSE syllabus proposed one book based on CESIL and a second on BASIC, and the panel split evenly over BASIC.
Not everyone was sure what the takeover meant. Writing in the Journal of the Institution of Computer Sciences in April 1970, J. Barker quoted Dataweek, which had asked whether the computer industry was "about to start a new trend in education", or whether this was "another growing pain of the new technology". Either way, it concluded, something had to be done to improve computer education in schools.
The first ICL years (1969–1972)
The takeover was announced formally at a press conference at the Grosvenor House Hotel in London on 15 September 1969. Bryan Thwaites, John Hoskyns and Peter Hall, a director of ICL, spoke; teachers already using the course, pupils from the Westfield pilot and boys from Winchester College came along too. The first ICL-CES newsletter, in October 1969, reported more than 400 new enquiries as a result, and said that the team had settled into new offices at Computer House in London after the summer's teacher training at Godalming. The 1900 simulator was "in full swing" from 6 October (Newsletter No. 1).
The first school year was a busy one. By the summer of 1970, ICL's own Staff Training Centre at Moor Hall was taking over the teacher training courses from the CES team, and summer courses at Beaumont College, Windsor were training teachers to start the course that September. ICL Deutschland had adapted the software so that pupils could mark up CESIL programs on optical mark forms, skipping the punching stage altogether (Newsletters No. 6 and 7).
Alongside the sixth form course, the team started work on a "lower level" package for CSE pupils, which became Computer Studies Book 1. It went into classroom trials in 13 schools in September 1970, and by late 1970 CES had processed some 1200 programs through its bureau service, while 25 schools were having their programs run locally on 15 local authority or industry ICL 1900 computers (Newsletter No. 9). Book 1 was rewritten in 1971 in the light of the trials, and CES expected about 1,000 pupils in some 55 schools to start the full two-year course that September (Newsletter No. 11). By the start of 1971 the team was "six strong", with John Hammond joining from the City of London School (Newsletter No. 10). Book 2 followed in 1972.
In June 1972 Byron Williams, who had "been with CES since its birth", left to lead the Mathematics and Physical Sciences department at Llandaff College of Technology, and Colin Hampson-Evans became the new CES manager (Newsletter Vol 3 No 5). Officials were still keeping their distance. A 1971 note on computer education in schools by HMI Barbara Hornsby-Dutton recorded that her contact with ICL/CES was "informal rather than official". She had not attended any of its working party meetings, but hoped to, "especially as they are working on material for CSE pupils". Describing how schools got their programs run, she wrote that ICL/CES processed them for schools, "but this is very slow and not satisfactory" (Goldstein papers, GG/2/1).
By ICL's own later count, 584 schools and colleges were using CES materials in 1972 (Newsletter No. 29). In October 1972 ICL's Stan Magill told a Computer Education Group meeting that over 115 LEAs and 600 schools and colleges were using the material in the UK, with many more abroad (Computer Education No. 14, June 1973). A "C.E.S. User List" dated 17 August 1972 names around 470 schools, colleges, polytechnics and universities, from Abbey Grange Secondary School in Leeds to Yeovil Technical College, each with its local authority, along with a few users overseas in Australia and Jamaica (Goldstein papers).
The last pages of the file (1971–72)
In December 1971 ICL's Byron Williams wrote that the scheme now included materials for 14 to 16-year-olds of average ability, was used in some 240 schools, and was supported by 49 LEA in-service training centres. Before meeting him, an HMI colleague noted in the file that he suspected a little "artistic licence". Sibson's reply, dated 18 January 1972, is the last item: the centres were probably just existing facilities in 49 places, only a few running at once. The Schools Council's caution had lasted the whole way through. In fairness to Williams, ICL's own later figures suggest he was not exaggerating: by its count, 584 schools and colleges were using CES materials in 1972 (Newsletter No. 29).
Who's who
Robert Sibson (1912–1989) read mathematics at Magdalene College, Cambridge, graduating as a Wrangler in 1934. He taught in schools before joining HM Inspectorate in 1947, and retired in 1973 as Joint Secretary of the Schools Council. He was 56 when CES first approached the Council: an experienced inspector and mathematician in the later part of his career.
John Hoskyns (1927–2014) worked for IBM UK from 1957 to 1964, then founded his own computer services company, later the Hoskyns Group, which he chaired until 1975. He went on to head Margaret Thatcher's Policy Unit from 1979 to 1982, was knighted in 1982, and was later director general of the Institute of Directors.
Bryan Thwaites (born 1923) taught mathematics at Winchester College in the 1950s, founded the School Mathematics Project, and was Principal of Westfield College from 1965 to 1984, which helps explain why CES ran its pilots at Westfield and Winchester. He was knighted in 1986, and in 1983 co-founded the charity Education 2000 with Christopher Wysock-Wright. He chaired the CES Advisory Council through the 1970s, and turned 100 in December 2023.
Stanley Gill (1926–1975) worked on EDSAC at Cambridge and is credited, with Maurice Wilkes and David Wheeler, with inventing the subroutine. He was Professor of Computing at Imperial College and President of the British Computer Society in 1967–68. As well as sitting on the CES Advisory Council, he was a consultant to ICL in 1968–70, just before ICL took the project over.
Christopher Wysock-Wright (1938–2025) founded CES (ICL's tenth-anniversary account calls the project his "brainchild") and managed it for Hoskyns, acting as its main link with schools, local authorities and the Schools Council. He stayed on the Advisory Council after the ICL takeover but did not join ICL, staying with John Hoskyns to develop the American market (Computer Education No. 3, October 1969). He was still on the Council in 1977, by then with Russell Reynolds Associates. In 1983 he co-founded the charity Education 2000 with Bryan Thwaites. He died on 18 May 2025, aged 87 (death notice in The Telegraph).
R. P. Tomlin was Managing Director of CES at its launch in 1968.
J. F. Farrer managed the project for ICL from September 1969.
Peter Hall was the ICL director who announced the takeover at the September 1969 press conference.
P. B. (Byron) Williams worked on the CES textbook from 1969 (his initials are on the May 1969 chapter outline), led the CES team in its early ICL years, and was ICL-CES Project Executive by 1971. He left in June 1972 for Llandaff College of Technology, but stayed on the Advisory Council. By 1976 he was at Uxbridge College of Technology, where he became Vice Principal.
More of the people who worked on CES are on the People page.
Sources
Schools Council correspondence file, "Computer education in schools: an organisation established by John Hoskyns and Co. Ltd, for the purpose of computer education in schools", 1968–1972, SCC/355/363/014, Records of the Schools Council for Curriculum and Examinations, UCL Institute of Education Archives. The catalogue record spells the company "Hozkyns" and dates the file 1968–1971, but its latest items are from January 1972.
For the first ICL years: ICL-CES Newsletters No. 1 (October 1969), 6 (May/June 1970), 7 (c. July 1970), 9 (c. late 1970), 10 (c. January 1971), 11 (c. summer 1971), Vol 3 No 5 (June 1972), 29 (May 1977) and 34 (January 1980). See the newsletter index. Also Computer Education, the journal of the British Computer Society's Computer Education Group, No. 3 (October 1969), pp. 2–6, and No. 14 (June 1973), p. 33.
For HMI's 1971 note: Papers of Gabriel Goldstein, GG/2/1, UCL Institute of Education Archives. For the reaction to the takeover: J. Barker, "Computers and Education: Growing up with the Computer", Journal of the Institution of Computer Sciences, Vol. 1 No. 2 (April 1970), copy in the Goldstein papers.
For the CES notes on its aims and the 1972 user list: Papers of Gabriel Goldstein, "Computer Education in Schools" (CES) Project, 1972–1977, GG/8/5, UCL Institute of Education Archives (catalogue record). The notes are undated, but appear to come from the Hoskyns period.
For the who's who: D. G. Rogers, "Bronowski and retrodigitisation", MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews (for Robert Sibson); Wikipedia entries for John Hoskyns, Bryan Thwaites and Stanley Gill; Science Museum Library, papers of Stanley Gill (for his ICL consultancy).